This is a response to Chapter 5, The Backhaul, of the book "Junkyard Planet" by Adam Minter
a.
India and China are both rapidly industrializing
countries with a large demand for resources, yet the vast majority of US scrap
metal goes to China. Explain why.
The reason why the vast majority of US
scrap metal goes to China is that the cost of transporting the scrap metal to
China is cheaper than to India. One reason for this is that India is farther
away from the US than China is. Also India doesn’t export many products to the
US, meaning that the backhaul for shipping companies will be empty. This takes
away incentives for shipping companies to ship to India from the US and back. It
is much cheaper to ship to China because China does export a lot to the US
making the backhaul profitable.
b.
Choose a passage from this reading that
illustrates a large issue or problem related to globalization. Explain.
Globalization brings the world
together, expanding markets tremendously. This expansion brings larger
incentives for companies to make products have a more competitive edge in the
global market. This incentive can mean companies cut corners to get that edge.
One corner companies can cut involves environmental pollution. This is
mentioned in the chapter, where India’s environmental authorities are
pressuring manufactures to stop polluting. Being green when it comes to
pollution costs money and discourages companies from being green on their own.
Globalization brings more
competition and more opportunities for businesses. These businesses expand and
with them pollution rises.
c.
More generally, how does modern transportation
relate to the themes raised by Jared Diamond in “Why Did Human History Unfold
Differently On Different Continents For The Last 13,000 Years?”
Modern transportation relates to Jared
Diamond’s article in that the countries that are not players in the global
markets and not involved in modern transportation, large container ships, are
countries that don’t have the resources, infrastructure, and economy to
participate. Many of these countries are the ones, because of the geography and
climate, which could not create as sustaining and strong civilizations like
that in Europe. Minter gives an example of this be explaining why Sudan is not
benefiting more from modern transportation and globalization. Minter says that because
Sudan “doesn’t have many factories” and is “without end markets—or the
possibility of such end markets” even with cheaper labor and lower
environmental standards than China, it cannot participate.
To add on, any country that has poor
geography to participate in the current trade routes. Mexico, for example, has
great geography because it has a lot of coastline on both the Atlantic Ocean
and Pacific Ocean. Brazil is a country that has poorer geography because it
only has convenient potential shipping routes in the Atlantic Ocean. Even with
the Panama Canal, shipping companies have built ships that are too big for the
canal making Brazil less easily accessible.